Is Agave Better Than Sugar: 101 Health Guide

is agave better than sugar
By Brent Hofacker on Shutterstock

Want to know is agave better than sugar? Then why did you stop, keep reading? 

Agave belongs to genus monocots, native to warm and arid regions in the southern United States, like Latin America. However, some agave species are also found near tropical areas of South America.

The class Agave is fundamentally known for its juicy and xerophytic species that ordinarily shape huge rosettes of solid, meaty leaves.

Miel de agave used to sweeten foods is formulated from the agave plant sap.

Stay with us to know, is agave better than sugar?

Facts about Agave plant

shutterstock 1938171616
By Al More on Shutterstock

The Agave plant is specialized for its sweetening properties. In ancient times, Agave was used for medicinal purposes. Agave sugars are fermented to make tequila. Eventually, it became popular in the health and wellness world.

It is considered a healthier substitute for sugar and a diabetic-friendly sweetener. But the question here is, is it?

The agave plant grows from the southwestern U.S. through the northern part of South America. It’s the same plant used to produce tequila in Mexico.

Most of the agave sweeteners originate from the blue agave plant. The agave plant moreover produces nectar containing huge sums of sugar called fructose.

Many health-conscious people are directed away from refined white sugar and pick agave nectar or stevia to satisfy their sugar needs. These elective sweeteners are frequently more characteristic or less highly processed than table sugar and counterfeit sweeteners.

However, both are determined from multistep preparing strategies.

Agave nectar is processed by heat, altering crude agave’s natural nutrition values and bringing down its antioxidant content.

It subsequently does not have a noteworthy nutritional value and contains lesser potassium, calcium, and magnesium. Agave contains less glucose and more fructose. The plant’s core contains aguamiel, the sweet substance used to produce agave syrup.

What is agave syrup, and what are its nutritional facts

Agave syrup is commonly used to replace sugar, honey, or maple syrup. After extracting the juice from the fruit, it is cleaned, processed, and concentrated into a syrup.

shutterstock 703014676
By Brent Hofacker on Shutterstock

It’s an exceedingly refined extract that sustains the craving for sweet-tasting nourishments and drinks. High Fructose Corn Syrup is cheaper and sweeter but leads to insulin resistance and is unsafe to intake.

Its flavor resembles molasses that become darker in color. If you prefer a low caloric diet, whatever sweetener you use to bliss your taste buds like maple syrup, honey, agave syrup, use as little as possible.

Agave syrup is commercialized as natural and relatively healthier than sugar. It has a calorie and protein content similar to sugar but contains far fewer sugars.

Agave contains around twice as many calories as white sugar in this case. It’s best to use about 5% agave for sweeter foods. The processing of agave syrup alters the raw nutrients in raw agave.

Agave and its Health effect

A higher glycemic index in the diet increases blood glucose content, indicating a drop in insulin sensitivity. The glycemic index for agave is low as compared to table sugar. So, we can say that Agave is better than sugar in terms of the glycemic index.

It also contains significantly more fructose than sucrose, which is sweeter, but fructose is differently metabolized than sucrose.

Some people have difficulty absorbing fructose and experience unpleasant side effects, including bloating or abdominal irritation. If you are experiencing digestive pain, you can avoid agave.

Agave syrup contains between 45% and 55.3% fructose and 18% to 30.5% carbohydrates per serving. Fructose has a lower glycemic index than glucose, but it has a much higher glycemic activity and causes seven times as much cell damage as glucose.

The percentage of fructose found in agave syrup is not similar to glucose and thereby gets broken down in the body in a different way, this might ultimately lead to insulin resistance.  So, it can often be suggested as a better choice for people who already have diabetes.

However, agave syrup is not recommended due to its high fructose content (sometimes higher than fructose wheat syrup). The plant-releasing Agave nectar is a more natural, healthier alternative to table sugar that doesn’t spike blood sugar levels as much.

The adverse effect of High fructose content

Agave Nectar: A sweetener that’s even worse

shutterstock 1561143944
By ZikG on Shutterstock

Individuals prone to gastrointestinal discomfort must take a step away from agave. Agree that it has less sugar content and will have minimal impact on your blood sugar levels due to its low GI score, but the high fructose content may make it more difficult for your body to process.

Glucose and fructose look comparatively the same, but they have entirely diverse impacts on your body.

Glucose is an inconceivably imperative molecule. It is found in numerous healthy nourishments, such as natural products and vegetables, and your body produces it to create beyond any doubt that you continuously have enough.

In reality, all living cells harbor glucose since this molecule is imperative to live.

Devouring excess added fructose can wreak havoc on your metabolic health and may contribute to insulin resistance, metabolic syndrome, heart disease, and type 2 diabetes, as suggested by various studies.

As already mentioned earlier, agave contains 85% of fructose, which is more than a normal body intake.

This can cause significant increases in long-term blood sugar and insulin levels, strongly raising your risk of metabolic syndrome and type 2 diabetes.

High fructose consumption can increase LDL (bad) cholesterol and oxidize LDL.

It may also cause belly fat accumulation, as suggested by another study.

Is agave syrup the best sweetener for diabetes?

Agave syrup is a high-fructose sweetener that offers more calories than table sugars. Table sugar contains sucrose that is deadly to the elderly or persons with diabetes. Nonetheless, fructose is a different sugar type linked with fatty liver disease.

Agave offers no miraculous health benefits, as its high fructose content has harmful effects on diabetes.

People with diabetes should avoid adding sugar wherever possible. Studies on mice eating agave nectar had lower blood glucose levels than those consuming table sugar and losing weight.

So, Agave may be marginally better than table sugar, but it does not necessarily constitute an excellent addition to the diet. Using a healthy diet to prevent diabetes can help reduce one’s intake instead of swapping between two different foods that contain sugar.

What are the healthiest alternative sweeteners?

Alternative sweeteners are regularly seen as more characteristic or less highly processed than table sugar and counterfeit sweeteners.


shutterstock 495319399
By HandmadePictures on Shutterstock

Stevia is considered a low-calorie sweetener inferred from the takes off of the South American bush Stevia rebaudiana. Stevia leaves and extricates sold as tabletop sweeteners in characteristic nourishment stores.

This plant-based sweetener can be extricated from one of two compounds called glycosides — stevioside and rebaudioside A. These compounds don’t contain any calories and may taste marginally distinctive from sugar.

Sugar alcohols

shutterstock 1894192567
By on Shutterstock

Sugar alcohols, too known as polyols, are a sort of carbohydrate typically found in natural products and vegetables. Popular sugar alcohols utilized as sugar choices incorporate erythritol, xylitol, and maltitol.

The microbes in your mouth don’t age sugar alcohols, so they don’t harm your teeth the way that standard sugar does.

Additionally, they have significantly fewer calories and don’t essentially influence blood sugar levels, making them a savvy elective for those with diabetes. Erythritol contains 0.2 calories per gram, whereas xylitol gives 2.4 calories per gram. For reference, sucrose — or table sugar packs have 4 calories per gram.

Although sugar alcohols are considered, for the most part, secure, a few may cause stomach-related disturbances when consumed in massive amounts.

Monk fruit sweetener

shutterstock 1316393264
By Eskymaks on Shutterstock

Monk natural product extricate derived from the Siraitia grosvenorii plant, local to China.

This sweetness comes from compounds called mogrosides.


mona mok wx4A5w85Sm8 unsplash
Photo by Mona Mok on Unsplash

Dates are the dried natural products of the date palm tree. These sweet, chewy natural products are an amazing elective to refined sugar and offer health benefits.

Unlike refined sugar and numerous other sweeteners, dates are a great source of supplements, counting fiber, potassium, magnesium, manganese, vitamin B6, and carotenoid and polyphenol cancer prevention agents.

Their sweet taste of dates makes them favorable for different recipes for energy bars, cakes, and cookies. Furthermore, you can blend them to flavor homemade nut pints of milk and smoothies.

Dates having high in calories and normal sugars, but they don’t essentially influence blood sugar levels as table sugar does, indeed among individuals with diabetes.

In a 16-week study of 100 people with type 2 diabetes, one group ate 3 dates daily, and the other ate none. The date-eating group had significant reductions in total and LDL (bad) cholesterol, while their HbA1c — a marker of long-term blood sugar control — remained unaltered.

Applesauce and other fruit purées

shutterstock 761557831
By PHILIPIMAGE on Shutterstock

Supplanting sugar with applesauce — or purées of other natural products like bananas — is an amazing way to diminish your refined sugar admissions.

Consider this swap in formulas for cakes, treats, biscuits, and bread. All-natural products offer well-being benefits due to their supplements. For case, squashed bananas are tall in folate, manganese, magnesium, and vitamins B6 and C.

Yacon syrup

shutterstock 1092850061
By: Amawasri Pakdara on Shutterstock

Yacon syrup is extricated from the yacon plant (Smallanthus sonchifolius), local to South America. Its sweet taste, dull color, and thick consistency make it comparable to molasses.

This item is wealthy in fructooligosaccharides, a sort of sugar particle that your body can’t process. Since these sugar atoms are undigested, yacon syrup contains one-third of the calories of regular sugar or approximately 1.3 calories per gram.

In any case, yacon syrup is less sweet than table sugar, so you will require more to coordinate the sweetness of refined sugar. The fructooligosaccharides in yacon syrup may offer well-being benefits.

For case, these compounds act as prebiotics, which offers assistance to bolster the inviting microbes in your intestine.


shutterstock 700711426
By: Kovaleva_Ka on Shutterstock

It has trace amounts of vitamins and minerals and an abundance of plant compounds that give anti-inflammatory and antioxidant benefits.

Additionally, honey has a lower GI value than sugar, so it is a safe alternative. But one thing to keep a note of is that it is slightly sweeter than sugar.

Is agave better than sugar: Conclusion?

After knowing everything about agave, we can say that agave is more natural and less harmful than sugar. It is not a healthy replacement.

It has more calories than table sugar. And it doesn’t add much nutrition value to your diet. And since agave nectar has a much higher content of fructose than table sugar, it causes severe health effects in the long run.

So, if you think of cutting sugar entirely and looking for an alternative, we would say agave is not the way to go.

Instead, go for other much healthier choices such as stevia, xylitol.


While at times contributed by guest authors, our content is medically reviewed periodically by professionals for accuracy and relevance. We pride ourselves on our high-quality content and strive towards offering expertise while being authoritative. Our reviewers include doctors, nurses, mental health professionals, and even medical students. 

Do note that any information found on the site does not constitute legal or medical advice. Should you face health issues, please visit your doctor to get yourself diagnosed. Icy Health offers expert opinions and advice for informational purposes only. This is not a substitute for professional medical advice.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here