Is Tea less Acidic than Coffee?: What’s in your cup?

Coffee and tea are all-time favourites, each with its taste, cultural overlay, and healthcare advantage. These drinks become intertwined with daily life and offer both a refuge from stress and moments of sharing with others in taste and smell. But within the fragrance of freshly ground beans and slow-brewed leaves lies a discussion as complex as acidity’s influence on our future bodies.

Acidity is not just a sensational matter; it is a defining characteristic that governs tea and coffee’s flavour and health benefits. Although acidity is, to some degree, a key feature in coffee’s flavorful complexity and tea’s subtly distinct aroma. Many are left questioning whether it provides optimum digestive comfort, a healthy dental concern, or a physiological benefit.

So, let’s move on to each subtopic to examine in depth how the acidity of teas and coffees affects health in various ways.

1. Tea: A Gentle Brew?

Clear Glass Pitcher And Kettle

A journey of tea through the history of humanity is as colourful and flavorful as top Instagram pictures. The story says that as far back as 2737 BCE, Shen Nong, a Chinese emperor by birth, was the first to accidentally drop tea leaves into boiling water and discover tea. Since this happy stroke of fortune, tea has been deeply embedded in Chinese culture as more than just a mere drink, but in the form of hospitality, respect, and spiritual benefits.

The prevalence of tea on the world map came about quite slowly and followed a trade and cultural exchange route. It was established in China, but from there, it flowed to Japan and made its rhythm in the spirit of Chanoyu, or the Japanese tea ceremony, promoting meditation and simplicity.

At first, tea was of little interest to the broader population, as it was reserved for the wealthy classes. The game not only promoted maritime trade but also had a profound impact on historical developments, such as “The Opium Wars.”

But what about the fact that it’s acidic too? Even though tea is appreciated for its worldwide fame around the globe, it is quite understandably overshadowed by its caffeinated counterpart, coffee, in conversations about acidity. Coffee is known for its high acidity level; on the other hand, tea is more likely to be viewed as a more neutral choice of drink. This discrepancy can be attributed to several factors, including:

1.1. pH Level

The pH value of tea brew is generally between 4.9 and 5.5, which counts the tea as slightly acidic. Yet, the pH levels could differ according to the kinds of tea, brewing method, and water quality available at the time of drinking. 

For instance, black tea has a pH that is usually lower than other variants of tea, which could be attributed to how it is produced.

1.2. Types of Acids

Tea components are the umbrella name for organic acids, which assist in producing different characteristic flavours. Oxalic acid and tannic acid are abundant in black tea and are the leading causes of its astringent flavour. 

Citric acid, a flavour enhancer in citric fruits such as lemons or oranges, leaves some tea types with a tart taste. Malic acid is another key element in high-quality tea, discovered naturally in apples and other fruits.

It provides crispness, brightness, and appealing tartness to some tea varieties. These acids, with others, make up this delicate balance, which gives rise to the tea variety that tea lovers like to indulge in.

1.3. Antioxidants

The unique feature of tea that gives it an edge as a beverage is its rich antioxidant content. The level of catechins, a subset of the flavonoid antioxidants, is particularly high in green tea.

In fact, green tea has been the subject of many studies, and catechins have displayed multiple beneficial effects on the human body. These exhibit antioxidant act not only as part of the benefits of tea but also aid in neutralizing the perceived acidity of flavours via their interaction with taste receptors.

1.4. Brewing Method

Being involved in making tea is a skilful process with several key steps to ensure the tea tastes and smells its best. That selection process starts with the choice of a particular type of tea and proper water temperature, which changes depending on whether the tea is brewing black, green, or white. Water is heated to the desired temperature. Then, the tea leaves are added and allowed to steep for a certain period, usually from one to five minutes, so the flavour particles in the leaves can be released into the water.

This matter gets very defining because of the strength of the acidity of the tea-to-water proportion. Last but not least, the kind of water you use can also affect the taste.

2. Coffee: Bold and Robust, but Acidic?

Person Performing Coffee Art
Chevanon Photography / Pexels

Coffee originally came from the mountains of Ethiopia, and this discovery is wrapped in legends. According to stories, a flock of goats was grazing among the coffee cherries one day and behaved abnormally after consuming them.

While it was a coincidence, this strange event led a curious local to test the berries. He became more energetic and even claimed that he was full of more fundamental bodily power. Coffee started from small beginnings in the Arabic region before slowly occupying an esteemed place in people’s social and spiritual gatherings. 

Around the 15th century, coffeehouses, or “Qahveh Khaneh,” that served as centres for intensive debating and interaction, were identified in the Middle East. Coffee’s booming popularity was indeed a fact, while coffeehouses spread over European streets.

Now, however, all over the world, coffee has become something of a phenomenon that people of all nationalities and cultures prefer to have on their tables for its pleasant flavour and stimulating effects. While coffee is great for many people, some people with a weak stomach find its acidity levels to pose an issue as they lead to indigestion and other stomach issues. Adhering to the reasons contributing to the acidity, we will talk about the acidity of coffee and its impact compared to other beverages.

2.1. pH Level

The approximate pH of brewed coffee is 4.8 to 5.0, which is more acidic than tea on average. This pH level can differ based on factors such as the kind of coffee beans, roasting level, and brewing technique. 

When it comes to lighter roasts, there is a greater tendency to leave their acidity compared to darker roasts, which undergo longer roasting periods during which they can lose their acidity.

2.2. Types of Acids

Coffee consists of a few organic acids, each responsible for its complex flavour. Chlorogenic acid, dominant in coffee beans, is the most significant acid contributing to coffee’s famous bitterness and acidity.

Roasting creates quinic acid, which adds sharpness to the brew, and acetic acid adds overall acidity.

2.3. Roast Level

The roast level has a big influence on the acidity of the coffee beans. Lighter roasts, roasted for less time and at lower temperatures, preserve a higher acidity, while darker roasts have a lower acidity. 

The acids in the coffee beans undergo some chemical reactions that change their composition and taste; therefore, the coffee brew becomes smoother and less acidic.

2.4. Brewing Method

The acidity of the coffee may not be the same if the brewing method used to prepare it is different from usual. For instance, cold brewing and espresso-making techniques frequently cause a low acid content compared to drip brewing and the French press method. 

Cold brewing comes from steeping ground coffee beans that have coarse grinds in cold water for an extended period, producing a clean, less acidic drink. The espresso brewing method, however, differs from the longer extraction method. In that coffee beans are finely ground, and hot water is forced to pass through them under high pressure, thus extracting less acidity than the longer method.

3. Health Implications

Taste and acidity are not the only properties of tea and coffee that I find beneficial to my health. It’s also a factor in the choices of most consumers.

3.1. Tea Health Benefits

Tea, especially green and white tea, is considered a perfect source of antioxidants, including catechins and polyphenols, associated with multiple health advantages. In addition to their antioxidant properties, these have anti-inflammatory, antimicrobial, and neuroprotective functions, making it possible to prevent chronic diseases such as heart disease, cancer, and neurodegenerative disorders.

In addition, tea drinking is good for the cardiovascular system; blood pressure is reduced, and cognitive performance is also enhanced. Combining caffeine and L-theanine, a dopamine-rich alkaloid in green tea, may promote alertness and concentration without the nervous side effects often linked to coffee.

3.2. Coffee Health Benefits

Similarly, coffee has many health advantages, which are possible because of its high amount of antioxidants and bioactive substances. Research indicates that indirect coffee use could be associated with a low probability of getting type 2 diabetes, Parkinson’s disease, and some types of cancer, such as liver and colorectal cancer.

In addition, caffeine, a primary natural stimulant, is linked to mental alertness, mood, and athletes’ physical performance. Caffeine has also been indicated to increase the metabolic rate and the fat oxidation process. Many dieticians include it in their fat-killing diets.

Nevertheless, we have to acknowledge that this is in terms of adverse effects. Every person’s body differs in its sensitivity to caffeine, with some people being more sensitive than others.

4. Considerations for Sensitive Individuals

Woman Holding White Cup
Pixabay / Pexels

For people with sensitive stomachs or acid reflux, it might be wise to choose less acidic drinks or use brewing methods to reduce discomfort. Choosing decaffeinated tea or coffee for the caffeine-free version may also help relieve heartburn and gastrointestinal problems like acidity without sacrificing the flavour and aroma of their favourite drinks.

Besides, natural teeth cleaning techniques, such as rinsing our mouths, drinking water, and not brushing them right away, can prevent enamel erosion.

5. The Role of Brewing Methods

The singular essentiality of tea and coffee lies in their acidic nature and brewing style, which determines the final acid level of the resulting beverage. For example, in cold brewing, coffee beans are steeped in cold water, which slows down the acid-producing free radicals in the beans; this, along with a longer steeping time, results in a smoother, less acidic brew than the alternative hot coffee brewing methods.

On the other hand, the longer the tea brews with boiling water at a reduced temperature or for a shorter duration, the more it may help to ameliorate the tea leaves’ acids, resulting in a milder and less acidic flavour. By adjusting the methods of making it and, accordingly, the duration of brewing, consumers can create their own tea or coffee based on their taste preferences and acidity tolerance.

6. So, What’s in Your Cup?

The arguments about whether tea is more alkaline than coffee consider the balance of different factors, including pH values, type of acid, antioxidant content, and brewing methods. Although both drinks provide original tastes, health value, and culture, those who do not tolerate stomach-sensitive or acidic foods may prefer tea, as it has a milder taste.

Tea, which boasts a great variety of tastes and beneficial characteristics compared to coffee, can be a soothing and comfortable substitute for nervous people looking for something less powerful. Its antioxidant content, moderate caffeine levels, and lower acidity make it a perfect choice for improving overall wellness.

In contrast, its strong taste and invigorating capability seem to have created an absolutely widespread recreational category. However, coffee, being the more acidic of the two beverages, has unique merits as it helps boost human cognitive function and lower disease risks.

The final pinpoint is not necessary whether you start your day with piping hot coffee and wind down with a whiff of fragrant tea. Instead, the watchword here is moderation and mindfulness. Knowing what determines acidity in those drinks enables consumers to make their own personal choices depending on their likings and what they intend to achieve health-wise.

Then, whether you are savouring the complex taste of a freshly brewed espresso or getting into the subtle nuances of a delicately brewed green tea, fully embrace the diversified beverage world and take along all the sought-after experiences. Finally, conservation of time is not the point; whether it is tea or coffee, every sip is unique and beautiful.

Last Updated on by laibaarif



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *